Organ donation can help treat disease and save lives. New Zealand has a low rate of organ donation compared with other countries. How could this be improved?
Benefits of organ transplants
Developments in organ transplants
Transplant rejection happens when therecognises the transplanted tissue as foreign and destroys it. The first successful transplant was done in 1954 when a kidney was transplanted between twins. Because the twins were genetically identical, no suppression of the immune system was needed. Since then, the use and success of has increased with:
- improved immunosuppression
- improved tissue typing
- better techniques for preserving and transporting organs.
Organ donation in New Zealand
In New Zealand, about 400 New Zealanders are on the waiting list for an organ transplant at any one time. Most of these people (about 350) are waiting for kidney transplants. Many will die unless suitableorgans become available. You can indicate on your driver’s licence whether you wish to donate your organs. However, your organs will only be donated if family members agree to donate them at the time. New Zealand has one of the lowest rates of organ donation internationally.
Would you be willing to donate your organs when you die? Why or why not? Would you accept a donated organ if you needed one to live?
Organ donation worldwide
Spain has one of the highest rates of donation – more than 30 organ donors per million of population each year, compared with about 20 in the US, 16 in the UK, 13 in Australia and less than 10 in New Zealand. In some countries, the rates of organ donation are higher than others due to social, cultural or legal factors, but invariably, all countries are unable to meet the demand for organs. Worldwide, there is a shortage of organs for transplants.
‘Opt in’ versus ‘opt out’ organ donation systems
Currently, most countries, including the US, UK, Australia and New Zealand, have an ‘opt in’ organ donation system where people say whether they are willing to donate their organs. However, the final decision on whether organs are donated is usually made by the family of the potential donor. It’s been suggested that an ‘opt out’ organ donation system could increase donations. In this system, donation is assumed to be compulsory unless people have already specified that they don’t want to donate their organs or family members refuse.
Whether an ‘opt out’ rather than ‘opt in’ system would increase organ donation is debatable. For example, Spain has one of the highest donation rates in the world, and this was unchanged when they switched from an ‘opt in’ to an ‘opt out’ system in 1979. Ultimately, organ donation system changes may ease the organ shortfall but probably won’t solve the problem.
Find out more about the ethics of organ donation.
Living or paired organ donation
A living relative or friend may be willing to donate a kidney to a patient, but they may not have a compatible blood group or tissue type. In this case, the potential donor andcould be matched with another pair in the same situation. This is called paired donation and may help provide organs for some people who would otherwise wait a long time.
Alternative sources of organs
Researchers are exploring whether animals could provide organs for humans. Animal to human transplantation, or , is being investigated by scientists worldwide. The technology has huge potential but first has to overcome issues with rejection, cross-species and ethical issues.
Stem cells are also being investigated as an alternative source of donor cells or tissue, but this work is in development and also raises ethical issues.
The Organ Donation New Zealand website provides information and statistics about organ donation in New Zealand.
Number of transplant operations in New Zealand from 2008– current published on the Organ Donation New Zealand website.
International donor figures from 2008– current published on the Organ Donation New Zealand website.
The United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) publishes the latest numbers of people waiting for transplants in the USA and transplant operations on its homepage.
To ‘Opt in’ or ‘Opt out’? – Organ donation in the UK, this is a 2008 summary of arguments for and against ‘opt in’ and ‘opt out’ organ donation.